Stephen Krashen's 5 Hypotheses, Explained Simply
A plain-English guide to Krashen's theory of second language acquisition (acquisition vs learning, monitor, natural order, input and affective filter) and what it means for learners.
Stephen Krashen is an American linguist whose theory of second language acquisition, developed in the late 1970s and 1980s, still shapes how many teachers think about learning languages. It rests on five hypotheses. Here they are, without the jargon, and with what each means for you.
1. Acquisition vs. learning
Krashen separates two processes:
- Acquisition is subconscious. It's how children pick up their first language: by understanding what people say. The result is a "feel" for what sounds right.
- Learning is conscious study: rules, conjugation tables, grammar explanations. The result is knowledge about the language.
His claim: fluent speech comes mainly from acquisition, not from learning.
For you: time spent understanding real German counts for more than time spent memorising rules.
2. The Monitor hypothesis
Learned rules act as an editor, or "monitor", that checks what you say. It works when you have time, know the rule, and are focused on correctness, like when writing an email. In live conversation there's rarely time to consult it.
For you: grammar knowledge is useful for polishing, but it won't make you fluent on its own.
3. The Natural Order hypothesis
Learners tend to acquire grammar features in a predictable order, and that order doesn't simply follow the order a textbook teaches them in.
For you: it's normal to keep making some "basic" mistakes for a long time. They usually fix themselves with more input.
4. The Input hypothesis
This is the heart of the theory. We acquire language when we understand messages that are slightly beyond our current level, which Krashen writes as i + 1. Context, pictures and what we already know help us understand the new part. Speaking, in this view, emerges once enough has been acquired; it isn't the main way to get there.
For you: the most valuable thing you can do is spend lots of time with German you mostly understand: stories, slow podcasts, graded readers, videos with clear visuals.
5. The Affective Filter hypothesis
Anxiety, low confidence and boredom act like a filter that keeps input from "getting in". When you're relaxed and interested, more of what you hear is acquired.
For you: choose material you enjoy, avoid situations that make you feel judged, and don't measure yourself by daily test scores.
Criticisms worth knowing
Krashen's ideas are influential but debated. Researchers have criticised the hypotheses as hard to test directly, and many argue that output (speaking and writing), interaction and some explicit grammar instruction also help. A balanced view: input is the foundation, and other activities are useful on top of it.
Putting it into practice
Comprehendr is built around the input and affective filter hypotheses: short animated stories at i + 1, lots of natural repetition, and no tests or forced speaking. Read how we apply the method or start with the first German A1 episode.